Choosing the Best Music and Video Streaming Service For You
Thanks to the proliferation of technology and the maturing of the Internet, you have more choices than ever for entertainment. Don't like what's on cable? You can stream virtually any movie or TV show you're interested in over the web. Sick of the radio and your music collection? Check out the 20-million-song music libraries available through streaming audio services. With a little curiosity and a few bucks, there's no reason you can't find something to entertain you these days.
But finding something fun isn't always the challenge. Now that there are so many options for streaming entertainment, the bigger question is which service (or services) you'll use. Answering this question is complicated because there are many competing services that have fairly similar offerings.
This article is helps you make the best choice by comparing the major competing options for audio and video streaming. The charts provide easy comparisons; these definitions explain each category. The good news is that you don't need to select a single service. I use iTunes Radio, Pandora, and Spotify for music, and Amazon Instant, Hulu, iTunes, and Netflix for video. Altogether, they cost me less than $50/month and provide so many options that I'll never be able to listen to or watch everything that seems interesting.
Streaming Audio
When it comes to audio, there are several issues to consider. This section covers the key criteria to use when choosing your ideal audio option.
Type: There are two major types of audio streaming services: jukebox and radio. Jukebox-style streaming services let you choose the songs and albums to listen to and the order in which you want to listen to them. These services are like listening to a CD. Radio-style services are like listening to the radio—less control over exactly what gets played or when—with some key twists. With radio-style services, you choose a song or artist as the basis of a "station" and then hear related music that the service believes you'll like. You can skip songs, giving you more power than a traditional radio listener. Some jukebox-style services, like Spotify, have radio features, but they're not as refined as established radio-style services such as Pandora.
Audio quality: Audio streaming is measured in kilobits per second (kbps). The more kilobits per second, the more data is being sent. The more data sent, the better the quality of the music. Higher is always better, but there's an important catch: unless you have very good hearing or high-end audio equipment, you might not be able to tell the difference between audio at, say, 256 kbps and 320 kbps.
Offline listening: You need an Internet connection to streaming music. Or do you? Some services let you download songs so you can listen to them anywhere, even when you don't have an Internet connection. You have to download these songs while you're online, but once you do, you'll be prepared. Songs saved for offline listening are available as long as you're a subscriber; downgrade or end your subscription and those songs disappear.Availability of apps: Virtually all of these streaming services can be used via a web browser, but some also have desktop and smartphone/tablet apps. The more options you have, the more flexibility and features are available to you.
Music catalog size: This can be deceptive. Of course you want a large selection of music to choose from, but even the most voracious music fan probably wouldn't listen to even half of the catalog available from the smallest provider. Pandora is an important exception here: because it operates like a radio station, it doesn't need a large music catalog. It simply pays radio-style royalties and has access to the same music. Its one1 million songs represent artists with which it has specific agreements.
Ads: Like traditional radio, radio-style streaming services include ads to help pay their bills. Some jukebox-style services include ads in their free plans, but remove them when you upgrade. Some people find ads intolerable, others feel they're a fair trade for free music; which type of person you are will help determine which service is best for you.
Song skipping: Royalty payment issues cause radio-style services to limit the number of times a user can skip songs in an hour and a day. Jukebox-style services have no such limits. You may not encounter song-skipping limits too often, but when you do, they can be frustrating.
Now that you know what the criteria are, Table 1 compares several options to make your decision-making process easier.
|
Google Play Music All Access |
iTunes Radio |
Pandora |
Rdio |
Spotify |
Type |
Jukebox |
Radio |
Radio |
Jukebox |
Jukebox |
Cost |
$9.99/mo |
Free
|
Free $36/yr – Pandora One |
$4.99-$9.99/mo |
Free
$4.99-$9.99/mo |
Audio Quality |
Up to 320 kbps |
TBD |
Free: 64-128 kbps Pandora One: 192 kbps |
192 kbps |
Free: 160 kbps $9.99 plan: 320 kbps |
Offline Listening |
Yes |
No |
No |
with $9.99/mo plan |
with $9.99/mo plan |
Desktop app |
No |
Yes |
with Pandora One |
Yes |
Yes |
Mobile app |
Android |
iOS |
Android, iOS |
Android, iOS |
Android, iOS |
Web app |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Built into devices |
Android |
Apple devices |
TVs, stereos, Blu-ray, game consoles, set-top boxes |
Stereos, set-top boxes |
TVs, stereos, Blu-ray, game consoles, set-top boxes |
Music catalog size |
18 million |
26 million |
1 million |
20 million |
20 million |
Ads |
No |
Yes Ad-free with iTunes Match ($25/yr) |
Yes
Ad-free with Pandora One ($36/year) |
No |
Yes; Ad-free with $4.99 - $9.99/ mo plans |
Song Skipping |
Unlimited |
TBD |
Limited; higher limit with Pandora One |
Unlimited |
Unlimited |
Streaming Video
As with audio, all the options available for streaming video could leave you reeling. This section covers the relevant criteria to consider when choosing a video service.
Type: There are two major kinds of video streaming services: subscription and pay-as-you-go. Subscription services are like cable in that they are always on and let you watch as much as you want for a monthly fee. Pay-as-you-go providers are more like video stores or pay-per-view: you only pay for what you watch. Both types have advantages, but pay-as-you-go services often have the largest selections of the latest movies and TV shows. Subscription-based services may offer the best value for many people, but they don't always have the content you want to watch.
Free content: Most streaming video services try to entice you using limited selections of free content. Amazon and iTunes have weekly free movies and/or TV shows. A large portion of Hulu's library is free. You probably won’t live on free content alone, but it's a great way to preview a service and getting something you want to watch for free is always better than paying.
Ads: Pay-as-you-go video services are like the movies or video-rental stores. Subscription services are like TV. The ones like TV-most notably Hulu, which is co-owned by a number of major TV networks-offer free programming, but in order to keep those shows free, they run ads. Free Hulu users will see ads at every commercial break. Paid Hulu Plus users still get ads, but fewer of them. If you can't stand ads, be ready to pay more each month.
Apps: All of these services have apps for smartphones and tablets. But beyond that, where can you watch them? Some have desktop apps for Mac and PC, others are built into home entertainment gadgets, many can be used on the web. When it comes to choosing what service to use, flexibility and availability are key.
Catalog size: You want the widest selection of movies and TV shows to choose from, don't you? The more options you have, the more likely it is you'll find something you want to watch (and all the better if it's a subscription service where you pay the same price no matter how much you watch).
Release dates: How long you have to wait to see the latest hit releases is another important consideration. Some services—especially subscription offerings—get many big-name titles months or years after they come out on DVD/Blu-ray and debut at pay-as-you-go services. If you want the biggest hits as soon as they're available, you'll have to pay for them through Amazon and iTunes.
Original content: Streaming video sites aren't only about watching things that have been at movie theaters or on TV. Increasingly, they produce their own original, exclusive content to give you more reasons to sign up. Think about the way HBO or Showtime creates shows to entice you into subscribing. Netflix is most well known for this with House of Cards and Orange Is the New Black, but Hulu (Booth at the End, Run) and Amazon have also gotten in on the act.Table 2 illustrates how the various steaming video options stack up against each other (these figures are accurate as of Aug. 2013, but change regularly).
|
Amazon Instant |
Hulu |
iTunes |
Netflix |
Type |
Purchase/Rental Subscription: Amazon Prime |
Subscription |
Purchase/Rental |
Subscription |
Cost |
Rental: $1.99- $6.99 Purchase: $9.99 - $14.99 Subscription: $79/yr |
Free $7.99/month |
Rental: $2.99-$6.99 Purchase: $9.99 - $19.99
|
$7.99 - $64.98/month |
Free Content |
Limited |
Yes |
Limited |
No |
Ads |
No |
Yes |
No |
No |
Mobile App |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Web App |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
Built into devices |
TV, Blu-ray, game console, set-top boxes |
TV, Blu-ray, game console, set-top boxes |
Apple devices |
TV, Blu-ray, game console, set-top boxes |
Movie catalog size |
65,000 |
3,744 |
39,000 |
7,574 |
TV series catalog size |
14,624 |
2,160 |
5,440 |
3,922 |
Release dates |
Same day as DVD |
TV: a day or two after broadcast Movies: Varies |
Same day as DVD |
TV: a day or two after broadcast Movies: Varies |
Original content |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
With these easy-to-compare charts, you should be able to start enjoying streaming audio and video in no time.