- Introduction
- The Need
- The Possible Solution(s)
- The Deliveries of Value
- Lessons Learned
The Possible Solution(s)
Once the team had a good understanding of what they were trying to accomplish, they decided they needed to identify options for realizing those objectives, starting with reducing the time required for commission payments. They used impact mapping (Chapter 14) to help them identify options. Several options came up, including simplifying the commission rules and consolidating the multiple commission systems into one. The team also identified multiple options for dealing with the existing systems:
- Build something in-house.
- Revise the existing conglomerate.
- Purchase something.
- Outsource all commissions activity.
- Do nothing.
The team decided that the best route was to start with simplifying the rules for commissions in one of the acquired companies to see if there was any impact on sales. At the same time, they started the search for software to replace all of the existing commission systems. Table 8.1 lists the characteristics that served as criteria for the search.
Table 8.1 Desired Characteristics of New Commission Software
Characteristic |
Required/Optional |
Accept inputs from multiple policy systems to determine commissions. |
Required |
Create unique commission rules for each individual agent. |
Required |
Support multiple hierarchies: some sales channels are organized based on product, others are based on geography, some are based on both product and geography. |
Required |
Allow for adjustments to occur in the calculated commission rules. |
Required |
Allow for manual determination of commission payments. |
Required |
Create unique commission rules based on free-form attributes and specific values of those attributes. |
Optional |
Support multiple commission rules unique to the individual, unique to the policy. |
Optional |
The team included the optional characteristics as a way of seeing if any commonly used applications used complex rule logic, in case they found data to support the need for unique commission rules.